If you’re a homeowner and find the dreaded expansion drywall anchor is spinning, you’re not alone—and you’re in the right place. In this expert-guided, SEO-smart article, we’ll walk you through why a drywall anchor spinning happens and how to fix it like a pro. We’ll tackle both the causes and solutions of anchor failure—making your repair fast, efficient, and lasting.
Why Does the Drywall Anchor Spinning Happen?
When an expansion drywall anchor is spinning, it usually means the anchor isn’t gripping the drywall properly. This can happen for several reasons:
- Hole too large or oversize: If the pilot hole is wider than the anchor, the anchor can spin freely.
- Stripped or damaged anchor: Applying too much force, especially with a power drill, can deform the anchor.
- Low-quality plastic anchor: Some plastic expansion anchors just don’t bite well into drywall.
- Improper installation method: Using a drill rather than hand-driving the anchor can cause twisting and failure
In short, the grip is lost—and the screw just spins inside. That’s when you hear: “an expansion drywall anchor is spinning as I turn the screw.”
How to Fix It When an Expansion Drywall Anchor Is Spinning (Step-by-Step)
1. Stop and assess
If you notice the expansion drywall anchor is spinning and won’t tighten, avoid forcing it. You risk stripping the wall or anchor further.
2. Try the toothpick hack (short-term fix)
If you’re in a pinch, try inserting a couple of wooden toothpicks or matchsticks in the anchor. Push them to the sides to create friction. This can sometimes give enough bite to hold the screw—at least temporarily
3. Remove and patch the hole
The more reliable method:
- Carefully pull the anchor out using pliers or pry it out with a utility knife, putty knife, or hammer handle
- Patch the hole using joint compound or spackle.
- Let it dry, then sand smooth before re-drilling a correct-sized hole.
4. Choose a better-grip anchor
Once patched and ready, opt for one of these:
- Molly bolts (hollow-wall anchors): These expand behind the drywall, offering a secure hold, especially for medium-weight fixtures
- Toggle bolts: Ideal for heavy loads, the wings open behind the wall and lock firmly in place
- Self-drilling (threaded) anchors: Easier to install and generally stronger than basic plastic tips
These options greatly reduce the chance of the anchor spinning again.
5. Manual installation is key
Avoid power tools when inserting. A manual screwdriver allows for control and ensures the anchor bites into the drywall correctly. Tampering too hard with a drill can strip or spin the anchor before it sets
6. Use a toggle if the wall is worn
When drywall is compromised, toggle bolts are a savior—they grip behind and are extremely reliable for heavier items
Real DIY Wisdom from the Field
On Reddit, several users shared helpful, real-world insights:
- “If you haven’t stripped the drywall and the anchor spins, try pulling the screw toward you when you drive it in…”
- “Sounds like you’re boring out too big of a hole… It should be so tight you need to smack it in.”
On DIY.StackExchange, users suggested:
- “You may have to pull out the anchor, fill the hole, redrill it and install a new anchor if the first one has become too misfigured.”
- “Try wedging two or more wooden toothpicks… creating a tighter fit that may be enough to lock the screw.”
These practical tips give a human, hands-on perspective to the solutions.
Quick Recap Table on Fixing Spinning Expansion Drywall Anchor
| When “Drywall Anchor Spinning” Happens | Best Solution |
| Hole too big / anchor loose | Remove, patch, re-drill, use better anchor |
| Anchor stripped but drywall intact | Toothpick hack or change to molly/toggle |
| Heavy object or compromised drywall | Use toggle bolt or molly bolt |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why is my expansion drywall anchor spinning?
Because the anchor isn’t gripping the drywall—usually due to an oversized hole, damaged anchor, or poor installation method.
Can I fix a spinning anchor without pulling it out?
You can try the wooden toothpick trick to create friction, but this is often only a temporary fix. Long-term, removal and proper replacement are best.
Should I use a toggle bolt if drywall anchor keeps spinning?
Yes—toggle bolts are excellent replacements for failed expansion anchors, especially under heavier loads.
What’s better: expansion anchor, molly bolt, or toggle bolt?
For light weight, expansion anchors are fine. For medium loads or more security, go for molly bolts. For heavy items or unreliable drywall, toggle bolts are the strongest option.
How do I install a drywall anchor without spinning?
Drill correctly sized pilot hole, press anchor flush, and hand-drive the screw—don’t use too much torque with power drills.
Final Thoughts (Conclusion)
Encountering a drywall anchor spinning can be frustrating—but you’ve now got the expert guide to stop that spinning for good. Here’s your action plan:
- Assess calmly—don’t force it.
- Try a temporary fix (toothpicks) if needed.
- Remove, patch, then use a higher-quality anchor (molly or toggle) if the hole or anchor is compromised.
- Always hand-install and use the correct drill bit size.
- Choose the appropriate anchor for the weight and wall condition.
By following these steps, you will end up getting your issue fixed.